CO129-243 - Public Offices & Others - 1889 — Page 626

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

619

Arrangements for Rating had for some time been considered, but fell to be unsatisfactory. After careful consideration, I was decided about to abandon the plan of Valuation done in spare time years ago, getting by Government Officer engaged in other duties, and to obtain a skilled Valuer from England. A properly equipped Valuation Branch was organised and attached to the Treasury. After some initial difficulties, the result has been unmistakable. Revenue has been materially increased, and the pressure of rates on the poorer classes has been relieved by a more equitable distribution of rating.

The expenses of the Valuation Office have been defrayed many times over by fines imposed on Chinese Owners of property for falsifications of their returns. The system by which the Government had been most seriously defrauded during many years was entirely broken. I believe the Governor was entirely with me on this matter. My anxiety as to the present position of affairs arises from the fact that when I absented myself, the late Valuer resigned his post. The only two members of the Executive Council who had ever paid any attention to the actual book on Rating, namely, myself and another, were both absent from the Colony.

I fear that representations may (with the best intentions, and in the best of faith) have been made to his Excellency to the effect that, the Rating having been got into proper, and, as it was imagined, final, order by Mr. Drooper, it might now be carried on by any person of common sense and intelligence. Such representations, together with a desire to reduce expenditure, and possibly to secure promotion for some deserving officer, may have induced a belief that a return to the amateur Valuation would not involve serious detriment to the Revenues.

But such a step would, under any circumstances, be undesirable, and at the present time, when commercial expansion and development are taking place, it would be deplorable. I therefore venture to ask from your Lordships an opportunity of reporting on this question, with a view to tendering my advice.

Edit History

2026-05-25 22:59:52 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
619 Arrangements for Rating had for some time been considered, but fell to be unsatisfactory. After careful consideration, I was decided about to abandon the plan of Valuation done in spare time years ago, getting by Government Officer engaged in other duties, and to obtain a skilled Valuer from England. A properly equipped Valuation Branch was organised and attached to the Treasury. After some initial difficulties, the result has been unmistakable. Revenue has been materially increased, and the pressure of rates on the poorer classes has been relieved by a more equitable distribution of rating. The expenses of the Valuation Office have been defrayed many times over by fines imposed on Chinese Owners of property for falsifications of their returns. The system by which the Government had been most seriously defrauded during many years was entirely broken. I believe the Governor was entirely with me on this matter. My anxiety as to the present position of affairs arises from the fact that when I absented myself, the late Valuer resigned his post. The only two members of the Executive Council who had ever paid any attention to the actual book on Rating, namely, myself and another, were both absent from the Colony. I fear that representations may (with the best intentions, and in the best of faith) have been made to his Excellency to the effect that, the Rating having been got into proper, and, as it was imagined, final, order by Mr. Drooper, it might now be carried on by any person of common sense and intelligence. Such representations, together with a desire to reduce expenditure, and possibly to secure promotion for some deserving officer, may have induced a belief that a return to the amateur Valuation would not involve serious detriment to the Revenues. But such a step would, under any circumstances, be undesirable, and at the present time, when commercial expansion and development are taking place, it would be deplorable. I therefore venture to ask from your Lordships an opportunity of reporting on this question, with a view to tendering my advice.
Baseline (Original)
619 Arra Rating had for Do been fell to be unsatisfactory. After careful three Concederation, I was decided, abou to abandon the plan of Valuation done in epare time years ago. getting by Government Officer engaged in other duties, and to obtain a skilled Valuer from England. A peroperly equipped balciation Branch. organiser anised and attache of to the Beasury. After some initial difficulties, the result has been and Ke Revenue unmistakable purexs. The Colony has been materially increased, D pressure of low of a Qubstantial reduction in the Accesment has relieved the rates on the poorer classes, more equitable distribution of rating has been decured. The of The Valuation effice have been defrayed many times in fact the total cart for the fines year dras more than mes by fines mereaved Oxpences Over, imposed don Chinese Owners of property for falsifications of their Veturns, Q system by which the Government had been most feriously defrauded duri during Many I believe des Bucelleniy he Governan was entirely with one on this Matter. My anciely as to the present position of affairs arises from the fast that that when I absoper. The late baluer, designed his feast. The only ties trember The Executive Council who had ever paid any attention to the actical book In Price, namely, and were both, absent from the Rating Kryself! Colony. I fear that representations may (Ith the best intentions, and in the Me Rating best of faith) have been made to his Excellency to the effect that, sextoon having As it tuould bo been got into prod, and, imagined, final, order Rente) by Mr Drooper, it might now be carried on by any person of Common & delegente Such representations, together with a dexing to reduce expenditure, and possibly to secure promotion for Rome deserving officer, may have induced a system of belief that a return to the ama tour Volecation would. Got involve serious detriment to the Revenues. ope exper Such an now, be un 4x desirable) under any But gues at the present Mongkong Creumalänces. time, when Commenung احدة L ao bebe ve period 7 bravke d A wowed. Q venture to expansion and development be deplorable. If therefore, ack from your Lordships an opportunity on this question, it is only tendering of reporting With a view f The advice of Bhould
2026-05-25 22:59:52 · Baseline
View content

619

Arra

Rating

had for

Do

been

fell to be unsatisfactory. After careful

three

Concederation, I was decided, abou

to abandon the plan of Valuation done in

epare time

years ago.

getting by

Government Officer engaged in

other duties, and to obtain a skilled

Valuer from England. A peroperly equipped balciation Branch.

organiser

anised and

attache of

to the

Beasury. After some initial

difficulties, the result has been and

Ke Revenue

unmistakable purexs.

The Colony has been materially increased, D

pressure of

low of a

Qubstantial reduction

in the Accesment has relieved the

rates on the poorer classes, more equitable distribution of rating has been decured. The

of

The Valuation effice have been defrayed many times

in fact the total cart for the fines year dras more than mes by fines

mereaved Oxpences

Over,

imposed

don

Chinese Owners

of

property for falsifications of their

Veturns, Q

system by which the

Government had been most feriously defrauded duri

during

Many

I believe des Bucelleniy

he

Governan

was entirely with one on this Matter. My anciely as to the present position of affairs arises from the fast

that

that when I absoper. The late baluer, designed his feast. The only ties trember The Executive Council who had ever paid any

attention to the actical book

In Price, namely, and were both, absent from the

Rating

Kryself!

Colony. I fear that representations may

(Ith the best intentions, and in the

Me

Rating

best of faith) have been made to his Excellency

to the effect that, sextoon having

As it tuould bo

been got into prod, and,

imagined, final, order

Rente)

by Mr Drooper, it might now be carried on by any person of Common & delegente

Such representations,

together with a dexing to reduce expenditure, and possibly to secure promotion for Rome deserving officer, may have

induced a

system of

belief that a return to the

ama tour Volecation would. Got involve serious detriment to the

Revenues.

ope

exper

Such an

now, be un

4x

desirable) under any

But gues at the present Mongkong

Creumalänces. time, when

Commenung

احدة

L

ao

bebe ve

period

7

bravke d

A wowed.

Q

venture to

expansion and development be deplorable. If therefore,

ack from your Lordships an opportunity

on this question, it is only

tendering

of reporting

With a view

f

The advice of

Bhould

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.